|
To millions around the world, Lewis Carroll’s “Alice in Wonderland” is merely
a childhood dreamland filled with riddles, fairy tails, and games without rules.
However, to the trained eye, Alice’s world translates into much more than a
child’s bedtime story. There are many undeniable patterns and connections seen
throughout his story that are simply too radical to be mere coincidence. The
story of Alice is both a mixture of contradictory patterns and a metaphor for
growth. With the right train-of-thought and a little imagination, this otherwise
straightforward fairy tale becomes a key to Carroll’s inner thoughts.
Psychoanalysts have analyzed Alice in Wonderland since the early 1900’s.
Psychoanalysis is,“ the theory of the talking cure.” In other words, it is used
to help understand inner (subjective) meaning. Psychoanalysis was first used as
a clinical practice to help people suffering from troubles without any organic
cause. (Bokay 2) However, it has also proven very effective in uncovering
subliminal motives in dreams, art, and literature.
The following should not be
looked at as definite concepts, but more like a key to help understand some
popular interpretations of lewis’ text. If the whole of Alice’s journey may be
read both as a passage from the surface to the abyss and as an achievement, a
hard conquest from the abyss to the surface, the leaven, the ‘engine’ of this
twofold passage is to be found in the series of events which are written in
Alice’s body. (Roncada 2) To grasp the concepts and to fully understand
underlying ideas in wonderland, it helps to think of wonderland as a real world
with real rules. Non-law and a non-measure of Alice herself govern wonderland,
which in turn results in a large amount of… nonsense. What is isn't, what isn’t
is, a very hard concept for young Alice to grasp at first. Alice morph’s from
tall to short, from small to big, and always maintains her psychological and
biological age. Her body (the engine) is disconnected from her physical life. (Roncada
4) Her body goes through four phases throughout this trip: 1) and unexpected
growth/decrease 2) a growth/ decrease openly driven by the other characters 3) a
growth/decrease manipulated by Alice (with bits of mushroom) 4) the spontaneous,
self induced growth without the use of any object (during the trial). (Roncada
4) This is the most obvious metaphor suggesting growth seen throughout Alice’s
trip. Alice does not look for any explanation for her re-occurring metamorphic
changes. To Alice, eating and drinking does not mean nourishment just as growing
up does not mean maturing or getting old; it is only used for alteration.
The
use of food in this world is not incidental. In Wonderland there are many
distinguishing factors between eating and drinking. The act of eating is not
“ritual”, it is necessary for Alice’s metamorphosis, it is a prize at the end of
the Caucus race, and a never-ending punishment at the mad tea party. The food
never becomes a real meal because it is broken into several snacks. (Roncada 6)
Food categories are separated into liquid and solid (which share the same
result: grow shrink), raw and cooked, and sweet and salty. A fine example of
this is during Alice’s first size change in the hall. When Alice drinks the
liquid marked appropriately “drink me” she states, “ It had, in fact, a sort of
mixed flavor of cherry-tart, custard, pine-apple, roast turkey, toffee, and hot
buttered toast.” This part entwines a number of distinct patterns contradicting
each other. First off, the liquid assumes the flavor of solid food. Sweet
(cherry-tart, custard, pineapple, toffee) and salty (roast turkey and hot
buttered toast) stay together. Inside the “sweet” category there are other
contradictory patterns: toffee is solid and custard is non solid; cherry-tart,
custard, roast turkey, and toffee are all cooked (or mixed) while pineapple is
raw and natural. And finally, the tastes have been organized according to
different culinary techniques: custard, toffee, and cherry tart are all made
with low heat and turkey and toast are made with high heat. Roasted Turkey, hot
buttered toast, and custard are all served hot while toffee and cherry-tart are
served cold. ( Roncada 4) This seemingly innocent observation made by Alice
contains too many patterns to have been plain train of thought.
Perhaps Lewis
had something else on his mind while he wrote it. In Wonderland everything has
the potential to be food, even non-edible items. The characters form a simple,
somewhat idiotic, pattern that combines food with whatever is at hand. For
example, during the tea party the Mad Hatter’s watch is smothered with butter.
This implies that WATCH=TOAST, which becomes clearer when the watch is dipped in
the cup of tea. (Roncada 57) This begins a new pattern of events which could be
formulated as-food on object-object is food. The Doormouse himself, who also has
been in contact with food (tea had been dipped on his nose) is eventually dipped
in the teapot as well. As the tea party continues, the relationship between
food, objects, and characters mingle further until no definition of eatable and
drinkable exist. This is seen finally as the Mad Hatter takes a bite from his
tea cup. It is here that Alice begins to accept food as a factor able to
influence one’s character: “Maybe it’s always pepper that makes people
hot-tempered…and vinegar that makes them sour…and camomile that makes them
bitter…and …barley-sugar and such that make children sweet tempered.” (73) There
is a special pattern through which Alice treks through Wonderland. Her journey
begins at the riverbank, she falls down the rabbit hole into a long narrow hall,
and from there she enters an open pool. This “open outside to closed inside”
pattern is a constant through Wonderland. (Brandt 4) Also, she is constantly
separated from spatial objects by her size. In the hall, it is impossible for
Alice to reach the garden because of her size.
|